My schedule is free but I come back in the weirdest place I could ever wish.
Let’s see what we have here!
Can you call someone maniac if it isn’t even manic? Stray Kids has truly sunk below the darkest times. Maniac is lifeless as it is predictable, lousy and tragic. The commodification of music in late-stage capitalism has accelerated the degradation of quality as it stands. We are hearing the stage of a rising genre where ciphers are common and half-baked melodies are habitual. I am just extremely in a point where I’d rather praise O.O than to listen to another reshash of the same thing in a different arrangement.
I would say Maniac has a not bad chorus, it stays where you’d what a song to settle. A hook that is very good for trendy 20 second TikToks. I am just tired of hearing this over and over again. JYP’s musical style has really broken in a delivish entropy. The verses are forgettable and I cannot remember a single thing about this except Maniac being repeated for 21986487246178461984619846 times. The bridge is the better part of this vacuum. I could feel it building to something elegant and flowering, however, the second after that is just the chorus which we’ve heard over and over. I’m just tired listening this.
Overall
I think this song is not for me. It’s basic and mediocre.
How about you? What do you think? Let me know your thoughts below!
Lyrics | C |
Instrumentation | C |
Rap/Sung Vocals | B- |
Direction | C- |
Structure | C- |
Cohesiveness | B+ |
Engineering | B |
Cadence | C |
Style | D |
Production | B |
Rating: C
Personal Score: 5.5
Producers: 3RACHA, VERSACHOI
Songwriters: 3RACHA, VERSACHOI
This article is about Stray Kids but this is how I generally feel with KPOP in general that it no longer surprise nor disappoint me. “It just exists” that’s what I feel to any release nowadays. 2019 is the last legendary year of KPOP I guess (I know everyone loved 2021 but I believe 2019 had more legendary songs in my opinion).
As for this song, I think this is better than Thunderous because the chorus here is better.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have to agree. With your thoughts on it being a better chorus. The song is also interesting however, it really falls short of everything
LikeLike
I just put a comment on thebiaslist now I’m here lol.
Imo, and although Maniac is like differently, technically, I have a feeling Stray Kids are taking its own formula and putting it in every title track since God’s Menu. I’m not a Stay, so it doesn’t matter to me, but I just wonder if other people think that. Not that Stays will care that much as well I mean they have the b sides to look forward to lol.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I agree. I do have an issue with it being to formulaic thus my low rating. Anyway, I look forward to hearing the album now that you suggest it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Funny thing about that. I haven’t heard the album yet, but I’m close with a Stay irl who listened to it she thinks it is their worst album to date. She thinks it has its moments though (forgot which songs)
LikeLiked by 1 person
Glad to see you back StillBangtan! I kinda enjoy this track, but I can see its issues.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Very splendid for you. How I wish I could say the same. It’s just so irritating that after finally having time to write something, it just ends up being ok for me.
LikeLike
May I suggest you try CHEESE? I think you’ll love this one, especially the lyrics. ♡
LikeLiked by 1 person